A recent announcement by U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has raised alarm among immigrants and those seeking to work or study in the U.S. The notice reclassifies immigration and border-related regulations as “foreign-affairs functions,” effectively allowing immigration policies to bypass the public notice and comment process required by the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).
With new immigration policies taking shape, many Green Card holders are considering whether now is the right time to apply for U.S. citizenship. Becoming a citizen offers long-term security and benefits, including protection from policy changes that could impact permanent residents. We also provide form preparation services for your other immigration needs. Check our services.
Eliminating Public Input: A Controversial Change
This shift exempts certain immigration policies from the procedural safeguards of the APA, which typically provides a 30-60 day window for public feedback on proposed regulations. While intended to expedite policy implementation, similar moves in the past have faced legal challenges. Under the Trump administration, courts struck down several immigration rules—such as proposed H-1B wage hikes and stricter visa eligibility requirements—for violating APA procedures.
Legal Challenges and Industry Impact
Indian IT companies, which depend on the H-1B program, may no longer have an opportunity to provide input on policy changes, leaving them with no choice but to react to finalized regulations.
Additionally, the foreign affairs function exemption could grant consular officers greater discretion in approving or denying visa applications, potentially leading to inconsistencies influenced by shifting diplomatic relations. It could also cause prolonged processing times and unpredictable outcomes for visa applicants.
Despite these concerns, legal experts believe there may still be avenues to challenge these changes. Recent Supreme Court rulings have made it easier to contest government policies that overstep statutory boundaries. While directly overturning the notice may be difficult, future rulemaking that invokes this exemption could be legally scrutinized, especially if it fails to demonstrate a direct link to U.S. foreign policy—an argument that has succeeded in past court cases.
What Lies Ahead
As this policy unfolds, significant legal pushback is expected, particularly from Indian-American advocacy groups and businesses that have historically relied on transparency in immigration processes. The coming months will determine whether the government can proceed with these sweeping changes unchecked or if the courts will intervene to uphold public accountability in immigration rule making.
With so much uncertainty around immigration and more significant changes expected in the future, immigrants need to fortify themselves. If you have been putting off vital immigration decisions, it is time to revisit them. As mentioned before we provide form preparation services for your immigration needs. Check our services.
